Friday, May 3, 2013

Rolleiflex Versus Phone Camera

 Number 1

Number 2

One of these was taken with my Rolleiflex TLR with Fuji 120 - Pro-400 film, and the other with my Samsung Galaxy S-II Smartphone Camera. I didn't try to hard to get the exact same composition, which is difficult anyway because of the old TLR's slightly vague framing lines ("vague" simply means that I don't quite know enough to figure them out). Exact same composition would've been nice, but I was really concentrating on getting the correct exposure and focus with the old Rollei, both of which on the Samsung being of course automatic. Can you tell which is which?

I would expect seasoned photographers who have that visually experienced sixth sense will see this as a no-brainer, and get it right at first glance. Others, who only have experience with Digital, might have some difficulty. I'm kind of in-between, neither a well seasoned film pro, but not a complete "digital dummy" either, and - here's a small clue --- I was quite surprised, even when knowing which is which. My surprise is actually how reasonably good the phone camera is.

Take your best guess and reply below.


Reader's comments are welcome, and are subject to moderation by the author.